Well, car is out!
Timing belt job was done on May 4th, 2016. Replaced the pump, belt, tensioner, and every seal possible! Also had my valve cover gasket replaced. The tensioner was getting loose which was what I could hear a bit, and the water pump was leaking, as well as a seal or two (don't remember which ones). The last shop to do BOTH of these jobs had not replaced the faulty tensioner (and didn't tell me about it), as well as not properly sealing the valve cover gasket and various gaskets under the timing belt cover. they also stripped one bolt terribly and left it which caused some headaches for the Toyota mechanics. Needless to say the last shop will be getting negative feedback from me, if I can hold back from burning the shop down :shoots:
I find it a little bit noisier than it was now at startup, however it seems to be running great after warming up! The Toyota guys recommended Mobil-1 synthetic 5W30 which was different than what I've used in the past.
The timing belt job was done at Toyota for a painful price, but I can rest assured that the two year warranty will cover any potential issues in the near future. 2 year/ 40'000km warranty on their service jobs!
Overall the car is running well again! Can't wait to start saving for something other than maintenance xD
Brad